Shingle Roofing vs. Metal Roofing – Which Comes Out on Top?

Reading Time: 8 minutes

Are you considering a new roof for your home or building? Learn about the key differences between metal roofing and shingle roofing, including cost, longevity, options, and more, in this comprehensive comparison guide.

Do you know homeowners love metal roofing as it can withstand severe weather conditions; but in terms of low maintenance and affordability, it’s the shingle roof that’s on the top.

So, while metal roof is ideal for longevity, the shingle roofing is perfect for budget-conscious homeowners.

Let’s, discover the secret to a roof that can withstand severe weather conditions, last for over 50 years, and even save you money in the long run.

Choosing what type of roof you put on your home or building is an important decision because you want to protect what matters most to you for years to come.

Today, we talk about shingle roofing and metal roofing and discuss the differences in terms of cost, longevity, options and more.

If you’re in a hurry, you can move straight to the end where there is a wizard that can help you choose the right type of roofing based on your needs. Just answer few questions and the wizard will help you get the best possible choice.


When it comes to shingles, obviously, I can just rip these apart and I definitely can’t do that with a metal panel. So how does that translate to a roof? Well, if you get metal roofing system that is Class 4 UL 2218 rated, you have the insurance of a proven and tested system that’s extremely durable. So, in terms or durability, I’ll go with metal roofing here.

Winner: Metal roofing


Your environment will dictate how long any roofing system can and will last. Asphalt shingles are said to last around 20 years, but that number can drop a ton in harsher weather conditions. Metal roofing is engineered to last 50 plus years in the right environment and on average, a metal roof will last two to three times longer than an asphalt shingle roof.

Winner: Metal roofing


It’s a common misconception that metal roofs are extremely heavy but they actually weigh about 50 percent less than an asphalt shingle system. The average 24 gauge standing seam metal roof weighs roughly between 1.3 and 1.5 pounds per square foot.

Winner: Metal roofing

Green Benefits

One hundred percent of the metal panels on a roof are recyclable. Because shingles are asphalt based, it makes it hard to fully recycle a shingle. In addition, a percentage of the material used to make metal panels is already

Winner: Metal roofing


When it comes to the cost of roofing, shingles are generally considered to be more affordable than metal roofing. Shingles are typically less expensive upfront, with lower labor and installation costs. However, it’s important to consider the long-term cost as well. While shingles may be cheaper to install initially, they typically have a shorter lifespan than metal roofs, which can last up to 50 years or more.

This means that over time, you may have to replace your shingle roof more frequently, which can add up. On the other hand, a metal roof may have a higher upfront cost, but its longevity can save you money in the long run, as you won’t have to replace it as often. Ultimately, both options have their pros and cons when it comes to affordability, and it’s important to weigh the long-term costs and benefits of each when making your decision.

Winner: Shingle roofing

Ease of installation

Shingle roofs are also easier to install, which can save on labor costs. This is because shingles require less time, skill and labor for installation and replacement.

Furthermore, shingles are more readily available, so there are more installers available to complete the job. Therefore, it can be easier to find a local contractor that specializes in shingle roofing.

Winner: Shingle roofing

Looks & Design

In addition, shingles have a wide range of colors and styles that can be customized to match the aesthetic of your home. This gives homeowners a lot of options when it comes to designing their roof and making it look great.

Winner: Shingle roofing

Overall score: asphalt shingle – 03 Vs. Metal roofing = 04

PropertyShingle RoofingMetal Roofing
DurabilityAverage lifespan of 15-30 yearsLong lifespan of 40-70 years
CostGenerally less expensiveGenerally more expensive
InstallationEasier and quicker to installMore difficult and time-consuming to install
Weather ResistanceSusceptible to wind and hail damageHighly resistant to wind and hail damage
Energy EfficiencyNot as energy efficientHighly energy efficient
MaintenanceRequires regular maintenance and repairsLow maintenance and few repairs needed
AestheticsWide variety of styles and colors availableLimited color options available
RecyclabilityNot as easily recyclableHighly recyclable

Let’s choose the right type of flooring for you

Here’s the wizard, just answer few simple questions and I’ll let you know what type of roofing will be right for your needs:

Step 1: Climate

What climate do you live in?

Once you’ve made your decision, there are a few other important steps to consider, such as calculating the length of your roof rafters and understanding how to overlap metal roofing lengthwise. These are important steps in ensuring that your roof is properly installed and can withstand the elements.

If you’re unsure about how to do these steps, be sure to consult with a professional or do your research to ensure that you have all the information you need to make the best decision for your home or building. Additionally, you can also check out our other articles on our blog which can guide you on how to calculate roof rafter length and how to overlap metal roof lengthwise.


Both metal roofing and shingle roofing have their own set of pros and cons. While metal roofing is more durable, longer-lasting and eco-friendly, it is more expensive and difficult to install. On the other hand, shingle roofing is more affordable, easier to install, and offers a wide range of colors and styles to match the aesthetic of your home. Ultimately, the decision of which roofing option to choose will depend on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. It’s important to consider the long-term costs and benefits of each when making your decision. It is recommended to consult with a professional roofing contractor to make sure you make the best choice for your home or building.

David Noah

Howdy, I’m Noah Although I don't like all this internet thing but I love sharing my stories on the roof here. With my years of experience in number of roofing contractors across various boroughs of Florida, I'm here to answer all your roofing questions. I'm really honored to have you on my website browsing through our articles and hope you'll enjoy your visit and find my content helpful in every situation. You can contact me right away to discuss any of your roofing problem.

Leave a Comment